Toddlers may be too young to understand Oprah's
weight loss secrets or guess the consonants on Wheel of Fortune.
But that doesn't mean adult
television shows have no impact on them.
According to a new study, background TV that's
prevalent in many homes may be detrimental to children's
development - even when they aren't
paying attention. The constant stream of sounds and images disrupt
children's imaginary games with trucks or dolls, and hinder
their ability to focus.
"If you talk to parents about what they're
concerned about, it's almost always the scary stuff and the
violence," Daniel Anderson,
a study co-author and professor at the University of Massachusetts,
said yesterday.
"They don't tend to think of games shows
or sports or Oprah as having any kind of negative effect."
However, the study of 50 children ages 3, 2,
and 12 months found that background TV "can be a very
affective distraction," from
the kind of play that's critical to helping children learn and
develop, Anderson said in an interview from Amherst, Mass.
Children at those ages have a limited ability
to sustain their attention and are just beginning complex
and symbolic play. So giving them
uninterrupted periods to practise and learn is critical, he said.
Pretend play allows them to develop important tools by refining
motor skills, exploring objects, role-playing and problem-solving.
The study, which appears in the July/August
issue of the journal Child Development, was conducted in
a lab set up as a playroom with
toys and a television. Each child engaged in solitary play for
half an hour with a television off and 30 minutes while an
episode of Jeopardy!, including commercials, played in the
background.
Researchers observed that when the TV was on,
the children looked at the screen for only a few seconds
at a time and less than once per
minute. But it was enough to make a difference.
"Specifically, compared to no television,
there was less play overall, shorter play episodes, and shorter
bouts of focused attention in the presence of background television," the
researchers concluded.
The kids who were exposed to the most background
television in their daily lives showed no better ability to
block it out, Anderson added.
There has been much debate on how TV affects
very young children, but most has focused on educational
TV programming or kiddie DVDs like
The Wiggles. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends no
television for children under 2, and most psychologists caution
that screens are no substitute for human interaction.
However, there has been little research on
the impact of background television, even though a 2006 survey
found that three-quarters of American families have their televisions
on "almost half the time" regardless of whether
anyone is watching.
Marie Evans Schmidt, lead author of the study
and a research associate at the Center on Media and Child
Health at Children's Hospital in
Boston described it as "a potentially chronic environmental
risk," and
said parents should limit their young children's exposure.